By Stacie Ballin
The 2026 horror movie Obsession has sparked a spirited online discourse about agency, consent, and violence.
We’ve seen think-pieces and comment sections alike debating one question: who is the real villain of Obsession? Depending on who you ask, it’s Nikki. Or perhaps it is the terrifying version of Nikki created by Bear’s wish. Maybe it’s the mysterious force behind the wish itself, or the people who knowingly sell wishes despite apparently understanding how dangerous they can be.
Then there is Bear himself. The nightmare begins when Bear wishes that Nikki would love him more than anyone else in the world. His wish strips her of the ability to freely choose how she feels about him, transforming her into someone obsessive, violent, and terrifying. So is he the one to blame, then, for the ultimate catastrophe?
At A Call to Men, we know that the answer is more complicated than pinning it on one villain. Bear is responsible for his wish, which was possessive and dehumanizing to Nikki. But that wish didn’t come from nowhere. It came from a young man who has absorbed the teachings of the Man Box: the expectations and social norms so many of us are steeped in from a young age, where men are meant to be in control and unafraid, and where women are treated as objects and as having less value than men. That socialization is the real villain of Obsession, and Bear is the lens through which we can see it.
So what does Obsession teach us about our own real-world communities?
Kindness Does Not Equal Consent
Some moviegoers have argued that Nikki knew Bear had feelings for her and took advantage of them anyway. But since when does giving someone a ride create an expectation of romantic access? When does knowing someone has feelings for you become an obligation to manage those feelings? Nikki did not owe Bear a relationship because he cared about her.
Within the confines of the Man Box, a woman’s friendliness becomes a debt, her attention becomes a prize, and her feelings become something a man is entitled to win or take. Bear’s wish doesn’t ask for Nikki’s love, but assigns it. Along the way, the film makes clear that Nikki had boundaries all along: she was uncomfortable when Bear probed how she saw him, and visibly annoyed when he tried out a nickname on her that she didn’t like. Her friendship was real, and it deserved respect on its own terms.
At first, it’s easier to defend Bear because he does not fully understand what his wish will do. He does not consciously decide to trap Nikki inside her own body or create a version of her that exists only to love him. But eventually he discovers that something is terribly wrong.
The real Nikki communicates with him. She is suffering. She is trapped. She begs for help. And Bear asks a question that may reveal more about the movie than anything else:
“What’s so bad about being with me?”
That is the moment when Obsession stops being a story about supernatural wishes and becomes something much more recognizable: Nikki doesn’t need to prove that something is wrong with Bear, she simply doesn’t want this, and that should be enough.
Understanding Pain Is Not the Same as Excusing Harm
It’s easy to see how Bear found himself in a place of desperation and selfishness. He is lonely. He is insecure. He wants to be loved. He struggles with rejection and seems to have tied much, if not all, of his self-worth to whether Nikki chooses him. Those are profoundly relatable, human experiences. Bear is not a monster, and that’s the point. Wanting someone does not make you dangerous. Being hurt by rejection does not make you dangerous. Being lonely does not make you dangerous.
The danger begins when another person being linked to you becomes more important than their freedom and autonomy to choose at all.
The film opens with Bear rehearsing how he will tell Nikki how he feels, and when the moment comes, he can’t do it. Anyone who has been afraid of rejection can recognize that feeling. When one person becomes the center of your emotional world, losing the possibility of being with them can feel like losing proof that you are lovable, that you are enough.
This is where the Man Box compounds the struggle. Men are taught to be self-reliant and to treat vulnerability as weakness, so a lonely, frightened young man has few safe places to say “I’m scared she won’t feel the same.” With no outlet for that fear, hurt can harden into entitlement. The person is no longer simply someone you want to be with. They become the person you need to validate your worth, and their “no” starts to look like something to overcome rather than an answer to respect.
Understanding his pain is not the same as excusing what Bear does with it. Once he suspects the wish is behind Nikki’s sudden devotion, he keeps going along with it. He tells his friends only part of the story, and he keeps enjoying what the wish has given him. We can have compassion for Bear’s loneliness without pretending it gives him a claim to Nikki. We can understand why rejection hurts without making the person he wants responsible for fixing that pain.
It’s on Us to Hold Others Accountable
Bear is not alone in the film. He has friends, and they notice something is off. Ian and Sarah are both uneasy when Bear offers to drive Nikki home. After the wish, Ian doesn’t like Nikki’s sudden interest in Bear. Bear’s friends point out that Nikki’s explanation for her new closeness doesn’t add up. And when Nikki’s behavior turns unmistakably strange at a party, everyone feels it, but no one directly questions her. Bear stays silent, too.
The warning signs in the film are familiar: a friend who suddenly seems watched or controlled, a man who treats a woman’s “no” as something to get around, a shift in a relationship that everyone feels and no one names. We can’t expect everyone to believe in a wishing willow. But we can expect friends to notice when someone suddenly isn’t themselves, to ask direct questions, and to take what they hear seriously. In the Man Box, men are taught to keep things light, to mind their own business, and to treat silence as loyalty. Silence is how harm grows.
Creating a Less Horrific Reality
Bear gets exactly what he wished for, and it destroys nearly everyone around him. Nikki survives, but she is left to face the aftermath of something she never chose. The Man Box does the same in real life. It costs women their safety and autonomy, and it costs men their honesty, their connection to each other, and their well-being.
So what can we carry forward from Obsession to create safety in our actual communities?
We can believe women the first time they tell us who they are and what they want, whether that’s “no,” “I’m not interested,” or “I’m not okay.” We can build friendships where men can say “I’m lonely” or “I got hurt” and be met with support rather than a punchline, or a plan to win her over. We can speak up when something seems off, even when it’s awkward. And we can teach boys, by how we act, that a woman’s attention is never owed and that asking for help is a strength.
A less horrific reality doesn’t require a magic wish, but it does require men to step out of the Man Box: to value and respect women and girls, and to value ourselves enough to live authentically and ask for help.
The movie asks us who the villain is. The better question is what we are going to do about it.